The Wrong Newsletter

The Wrong Newsletter: Yesterday's Weather

I keep a rain gauge on the back porch. Not because it tells me anything the forecast doesn't — but because I like watching the actual water land after everyone's already guessed at it. This week, a lot of guesses landed a beat too early.


81% of us figured Washington would blink on the Canada tariffs before Aug. 27. It didn't blink.

The 50% duties on Canadian goods took effect at midnight, days after a tentative "deal" got floated publicly and then quietly came apart.

Here's the thing about that pause — it was real enough that people got hopeful, and hope travels faster than confirmation. A deal gets leaked before it's signed, gets reported like it's done, and only later turns out to still be a fight happening behind a closed door. We priced the leak, not the fight. Carney was calling the U.S. demands "uneconomic and unfair" on his way out of the room, which isn't the language of someone mid-signature. The optimism wasn't foolish. It was just early.


80% of us had TCU beating North Carolina in Dublin. Final: Tar Heels, 15-10.

Belichick's first game in Chapel Hill was a 48-14 flattening at the hands of this exact TCU team, and a year later, that's still the number most of us were carrying around. Fair — it's a big number.

But a full offseason is a long time in football, and a new quarterback throwing for 232 yards in the rain is a different team than the one that got run over on Labor Day. We bet on the scar, not the roster underneath it. Rivers don't carve the same channel twice, even when the map hasn't caught up yet.


73% expected another weak jobs report. The economy added 162,000 — more than triple what Wall Street itself was forecasting.

Small comfort, but this one isn't on us alone. The professionals missed by roughly the same margin we did. One soft month convinced almost everyone that a trend had started, and it hadn't — a single point isn't a line, no matter how many people are staring at the same point.


We'll take the company on that last one. Next week's board is already filling in, and I'd rather find out alongside you than get ahead of it.

— Phil


This week's resolutions

Culture

Discovery

Markets

Politics

Sports

World