Judge Emmet Sullivan says Todd Blanche broke the Epstein files law and blew a Sept 24 deadline. Will he hold the AG in contempt by Oct 14?
64% of users predicted NO โ community got this one right.
U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan did not hold Attorney General Todd Blanche in contempt by Oct. 14, 2026, despite mounting pressure in the Epstein files transparency case. In a 20-page order issued Sept. 17, Sullivan wrote that a civil contempt finding would be "premature" at that stage, even as he faulted the Justice Department for missing prior deadlines and for providing insufficient justification for redactions in some files. He set a new deadline of Sept. 24 for the department to produce the disputed records, including unreleased FBI interview notes and foreign-language materials, or explain why his orders had not been clear.
The case stems from a lawsuit filed by journalist Katie Phang, who alleges the DOJ withheld documents required under the Epstein Files Transparency Act, which Congress passed in 2025. Phang's attorneys had asked Sullivan to impose a $1,000-a-day fine until the department complied. A DOJ spokesperson said department leadership was "not concerned" about the case.
No contempt order followed in the weeks after the September ruling, leaving Sullivan's warning unenforced as of the question's Oct. 14 deadline. The community largely anticipated this outcome, with only 36% of voters predicting a contempt finding by that date.